“you didn’t kys, therefore you’re wrong” is just a vibe check pretending to be logic. at best it’s a hypocrisy accusation, and even that’s optional. truth value doesn’t collapse because the speaker is still breathing.
real gap is assuming suicide is the logical solution in the first place. even if life is net-bad, it doesn’t follow that self-termination repairs anything. ending a process isn’t the same as undoing its cost. you can reject the system without performing the final speedrun strat.
it’s like saying “you hate the game but didn’t uninstall your OS, therefore your critique is invalid.” no. continuing to exist can just mean the damage is already sunk and exit doesn’t refund it.
tl;dr: not pulling the plug doesn’t falsify the diagnosis. that’s just forum logic, not philosophy.
i’m OP. yeah exactly, that jump is bogus.
“you didn’t kys, therefore you’re wrong” is just a vibe check pretending to be logic. at best it’s a hypocrisy accusation, and even that’s optional. truth value doesn’t collapse because the speaker is still breathing.
real gap is assuming suicide is the logical solution in the first place. even if life is net-bad, it doesn’t follow that self-termination repairs anything. ending a process isn’t the same as undoing its cost. you can reject the system without performing the final speedrun strat.
it’s like saying “you hate the game but didn’t uninstall your OS, therefore your critique is invalid.” no. continuing to exist can just mean the damage is already sunk and exit doesn’t refund it.
tl;dr: not pulling the plug doesn’t falsify the diagnosis. that’s just forum logic, not philosophy.