Recommend the guy above your post an anime to watch judging from the keywords he has given. Likewise, give keywords or bullet points (or even full sentences if you're so inclined) that explain what you like in an anime.
- believable characters - Character designs like those by Yoshitoshi Abe - surrealism maybe even - a romantic love story - cute girls Obviously there is no anime that can fulfill all those criteria, but you can make better guesses with more keywords.
since >>2 didn't follow directions i'll ask for - chuuni - comfy cute - attention to detail / emphasis on subtlety - well choreographed action - slice of life about something other than high school - talking animals / talking objects
- believable characters
- Character designs like those by Yoshitoshi Abe
- surrealism
maybe even
- a romantic love story
- cute girls
Obviously there is no anime that can fulfill all those criteria, but you can make better guesses with more keywords.